Wednesday, January 30

Notions: yay or nay

I wish I could dispel the notion that dancing is a sport. While I recognize its value as an intense cardiovascular workout and good route to muscular legs, real sports have points or timers, and sometimes physical contact with another team. Dancer!=Athlete.

I don't care for the notion that small talk is pleasant or necessary. As we walk back to our desks from the kitchen area, there's really no point in asking me what project I'm working on. That question really initiates an answer that is at least 30 seconds long, and we only have less than 5 seconds until we're at our desks. And then it gets awkward because you have to stand by my desk listening to me answer a question that you don't really care about. Let's walk back in silence; silence doesn't have to be awkward. It's only 5 seconds.

I dislike the notion that American Eagle (and Hollister, Abercrombie, etc) is for people who are followers. I'm tired of being subtly judged for enjoying a good brand. You haters say "I am unique, and therefore I wear unique clothing". I say "I am unique, and wear what I like. What I like happens to be what a lot of other people like. Suck it." Except since it's all really subtle, they never really say their bit aloud, and so I can't really retort with my bit.

I am bothered by the notion that working an office job means you've given into the man. We can't all be Starbucks barristas. I quite enjoy my 9-to-5-in-front-of-a-computer lifestyle. Working in an office doesn't mean my calendar is marked with Casual Friday and Office Retreat. (We're casual everyday!). Working at an office doesn't mean I work at Dunder Mifflin or wherever Dilbert works. Working in an office doesn't mean I chat by the water cooler about the bad management. Working in an office doesn't mean I've given up my dreams for the big paycheque and now I hate my life. Some people like offices.

I can hardly tolerate the notion that Information Architects are web designers. When I say "I am an IA" people either assume I can build them a website (no! I do NO coding!) or that I do graphic design (no! no!).

I cannot toleration the notion that all bloggers are here to be fantastic writers. There's been a fair amount of chatting around blogoland, complaining about the steady decline of writing quality. I harrumph at this crowd, and pump my fist while saying: Who says everything we post has to be fantasmic writing? Who says that by default we must all be here because we all love writing and want to write well and be Writers4Life? Not every post is life changing. Not every blog is life changing. I would rather read an interesting post than a well written post. Plus like half the stuff at IB really bothers me because the effort is often palpable and it reminds me of grade 10 english class when my teacher told me to try to be emotional in my writing. And not that my lexicon is huge, but it's pretty obvious when people use Thesaurus.com. Pretty obvious and pretty lame.

I abhor the notion that seems to be set in the minds of many people, mostly girls: That there is something you cannot do. I was talking to my younger sister's friend who wants to go into accounting. She said she was thinking of Waterloo, for their co-op program. I said "Waterloo is okay, but Laurier is probably the better co-op school for business, and harder to get into." She said "oh, okay, then it looks like I'll go to Waterloo." She's in grade 11! Plenty of time to work on whatever marks she needs. And she had already underestimated herself, thinking she didn't have the abilities to get into the top school. Seriously? Or did you know that almost 100% of girls who apply to engineering get in NOT because Admissions is easier on female applicants but because only females who are hugely qualified even apply. Meanwhile plenty of males who have grades 20% below the required average still apply. But girls don't even try for fear of rejection! GIRLS, COME ON.

I put forward the notion to get rid of all the aforementioned notions. All in favour?

39 comments:

B2G said...

I am SO WITH YOU on the writing rant. Ugh. A lot of times the effort on IB is palpable.

fort knocks said...

Wow, I agree with every single last one. I had a notion that I would agree with at least some of the notions you want to annihilate, but no such luck.

I propose adding figure skating to the dancing=not a sport equation.

Michelle said...

i'm with you. especially on the writing rant but you knew that already.

lspoon said...

I like that you call them "marks" instead of "grades". I find that to be awesome :)

PrincessPolly said...

the small talk and the writing ones hit home with me. I've read so many blogs on here that are brilliantly written but mean nothing to me. Sometimes I don't have a clue what the person is even talking about. it's like they're trying to create some sort of literary masterpiece masquerading as a blog. What's the point!

Jamie Lovely said...

I've been totally guilty of complaining on my blog about content. Mostly because it seems I have been focusing in on all the negative going on and I need to change that, not just when it comes to blogging, life in general.

Anyway, I'm really curious as to what an IA does. I honestly don't know, I don't think I've ever heard of it before. I hope I don't sound ridiculous and everyone is like OMG YOU DON'T KNOW WHAT AN IA IS?!

Shelley said...

I know that it's kinda lame that I looked this up on dictionary.com but I was curious: sport = "an athletic activity requiring skill or physical prowess and often of a competitive nature."

Dancing requires skill. Competitive dancing is intense... let me tell ya.

Nice rant!

ChasingParadise said...

That's a lot of notions! I don't know what is up in blogger land these days, but I'm not liking it one bit. I'm deffo with you on the small talk. Why do people have such a hard time with silence?

Lisa said...

I feel the exact same way about the writing. I have never made any pretensions to be a writer. I don't even WANT to be a writer. So what if my writing offends someone's hoity-toity literary sensibilities. I don't go to BLOGS expecting well-written prose. I read BOOKS for that. I read specific blogs because I'm genuinely interested in the people writing them.

distractedspunk said...

Agreed on most, but dancing is a sport. :) After you injure your body and can no longer walk without dislocating your hip once a week, have the bloody toes and feet, and mangled ankles to show it? Sure, it may not be timed, or involve much upper body strength, but to dance for long periods of time? Requires a different type of endurance than that of a runner.

Valerie said...

*stands up & cheers*

woo!

r.xo said...

This girl gives you a YAY! Way to speak the truth!

If I spent time worrying about how my blog reads from a literary perspective, I'd never write anything down at all!

tiff said...

bowling = not a sport.

This makes me feel a lot better about not getting accepted on IB yet,because maybe what I submitted was interesting to me, but wasn't 10th grade AP english enough.

Also? Love the word notion! Weeee!

Alice said...

so with you on the office does not have to equal "giving in to the man." just because i work nice, regular hours (which = all weekends and evenings free for WHATEVER I WANT) and make good money (which i can spend on WHATEVER I WANT) does not mean my life sucks. in fact, it means my life is kind of awesome.

i'm with distractedspunk, though :-) my sister was a classical ballet dancer for most of her life, and in addition to having washboard abs and bleeding from her feet after 9 straight hours of dancing, she also got stress fractures on her spine from it all. she went to the doc, and they were all "we're guessing you're not a varsity football player, so you must be a dancer. those are the only 2 kinds of people we see who get spinal stress fractures."

brandy said...

I like this idea, and I'm with you on all of them except the first one. I'm not a dancer but to me a sport implies practice, teamwork, sweat, competition and performance, all of which can fall into dancing depending on the route you take.

Miss Cee said...

Yay for 9 to 5 office jobs! Well, mine is actually a 7.30 to 5 office job, but still - nice money, regular hours and all that. It's a good thing :-)

Deutlich said...

I agree, wholeheartedly, about the blogging thing. Every piece of writing doesn't need to be this life-altering, motivational post!

And IB? Kinda gets on my nerves on occasion for the same reason.

Tina Vaziri said...

tewwwtallly

Katelin said...

I'm totally with you on everything, nicely said.

d said...

BOO YAAAA.

you know one of my best friends (one of us five who call ourselves 'the band') calls the rest of us "corporate slaves" because he's a math teacher?

he actually said those words.

we, of course, never let him forget it.

Vanessa said...

I'm in favor and will round up as many supporters as I can! Especially the idea that girls are somehow inferior and so many just sell themselves short as habit. We need strong women. Iron Jawed Angels anyone?

Justus said...

Motion, you put forward a motion not a notion. Just though I'd clear that up. Can you tell that it bothered me? Also, what is IB?

L Sass said...

Hilarious, as usual!!

Also, I am so glad blogging isn't all about fantabulous writing...

Cause if it was, I've FAILED!

Virginia said...

Hear hear! Especially about the blogging. It's a blog! Not a bestselling novel! And at least for me, I'm writing it for ME and if I get some readers, great. If not, I still enjoy writing it.

And I would also like to say that golf is not a sport. Also, horseback riding. Who is doing all the real work in that situation?

zandria said...

I'm not a dancer, but I think there are probably some professional dancers out there who would disagree with you about it not being a "sport." Technically? Maybe not. But effort-wise? Wow. (I've never watched Dancing with the Stars, but I've read a few articles about some of the stars who started dancing and got in fantastic shape.)

So what exactly IS an "Information Architect?"

Libby said...

ok, you? EQUALS THE BOMB!

hilarious and such a good post lise! amen, sistah. i guffawed particularly loud at the office one. and the writing one too. the ib point is very true!

Meghan said...

Thank you, thank you, thank you. I love my office job and management. I wear my hoodies on weekends with love and don't pretend to be a good writer, just an honest one.

Best post I've read in awhile:)

Miss A said...

Do I get strung out and decapitated at a town meeting if I reject some of the motions?

1. Dancing is not a sport. Okay, so the lack of clearly defined points / times make it a very subjective sport. But surely some dancing is so technical (ie. ballroom), that points could be awarded. Same goes for gymnasts? If I allow this motion to pass, then where does this leave gymnasts (who neither work on scoring 'points' in the sense of a 'game' sport or time)?

2. Small talk is not necessary or pleasant. Whilst sometimes I would support this motion, small talk is how we meet people and slowly get familiar with people. I think small talk has more pros than cons. I reject your motion.

3. Brand names (I'm not familiar with those you listed, but I get the gist) are not for followers. Ooooh, you put up a good argument here Lise. But really, you're practically advertising a company on a jumper or top, or whatever. Pay half the price for a plain jumper without the logo. With that said, I don't think waring logos makes you "un"-unique, because even ppl who don't wear logos are probably still wearing fashions that every 3rd person is also wearing. But back to your motion that it's for people who are "followers"... I think we are all following something, whether its a brand, other people, fashion mags etc. I'm undecided ;-)

4. Office job means you've given into the man. Meh, I do work in the 'typical' office environment, and I think that the stereotypes associated with offices whilst at sometimes may be true, makes us no different to someone who works in a shop and listens to the radio all day. My offices have always been very dilbert-like, so i gotta raise my hand in support of nay. sorry mate. BUT, working in an office DOES not equal UNHAPPINESS, so I'm with you on that part ;-)

-IAs. I'm yay on this one.

- Bloggers are not all writers. Gosh I am a BIG supporter of this motion. Our motivations are all so different for posting our experiences, thoughts, dramas or stories that it's impossible to assume we all 'want to be writers' pfft. thumbs up dude.

-Something we cannot do. Yeah. It's an unfortunate glass ceiling mentality we have even still in our generation. with you on this one.

phew. got threw them. i'll sit down now.

Ready, aim, THROW YOUR TOMATO NOW!

ana said...

Yay!

Hope said...

I am in complete agreement on brands. And I would totally use your retort, or maybe just the 'Suck it' bit. :)

qed said...

Trust you Miss A to reject some perfectly logical notions. I in turn reject your rejections and restore the natural progression of these hypotheses to their natural entropathic end. I say yay. QED.

Angela said...

I am in such agreement with you on the blogging not always having to equal Great Writing. I LOVE to write, however, I do that in an entirely different way than I blog. I think of my blog as more of a public diary, and I rarely so much as edit a post (which is kind of obvious at times!). And honestly, I don't read other blogs because of their Great Writing, I read them because I find entertainment value, or friendship, or a common viewpoint there. If I want to read Great Writing, I turn to my bookshelves :)

Stacy (IB) said...

I definitely agree with you that bloggers don't have to be great writers, but I have to say that I really appreciate that people care enough to read and submit to IB. Not all posts have to be fantastic - we're bloggers, not writers. I read the blogs I do because they have something to say and they say it well. I couldn't give a shit what someone had for breakfast.

I'm super proud of IB regardless of whether the effort is considered palpable. I love that people give a shit and actually try.

Princess Pointful said...

Okay, I'm a wee bit crushed because I was really happy to have a piece just posted on IB. ;)

However, I come from a very small hippie town, where people are aghast I *choose* to live in a big city, and even more aghast when they hear of me working for "The Man" in any shape or form. Right now, I work for the provincial government, technically, so I can only imagine what they'd have to say about me.

Lisa said...

Stacy, I said that with no disrespect to IB. Clearly I read it because lots of the stuff is AMAZING.
Also, as a fellow creator of a blogging related site (you=IB, me=20sb) I know that it feels kind of defeating to get negative feedback on all your efforts. I do appreciate your work at IB!

Gillian said...

I'm gonna have to disagree on the dancers. Those are some athletes. Now, let's talk about curling, or bowling, both of which are "sports" and have scores and such, but I think if you can drink while you're doing it, it isn't a sport. Just sayin'.

Chris C said...

The same people who will complain the posts are not 'writy' enough will whine that your posts are now too long and wordy. hehe

Nemo Dally said...

You and Dilbert are in a cartoon.

You: IA.
Dilbert: I see.

You: No, IA.
Dilbert: Yes, I see.

You: (storm off in a range)
Dilbert: I'm going to blog about acronyms.

Doesn't matter where your clothes are from so long as you stencil them.

love
peter

Nemo Dally said...

*rage (bad internet writing)